Inheritance Rules for Non Muslims in the UAE: .pdf
Original filename: Inheritance Rules for Non-Muslims in the UAE:.pdf
This PDF 1.4 document has been generated by Writer / LibreOffice 3.5, and has been sent on pdf-archive.com on 08/06/2015 at 12:54, from IP address 180.149.x.x.
The current document download page has been viewed 295 times.
File size: 20 KB (2 pages).
Privacy: public file
Download original PDF file
Inheritance Rules for Non-Muslims in the UAE: Mr. Hassan Elhais
Although Article 17/1 of the Civil Code of the UAE provides that it is the law of the deceased that
shall govern the inheritance at the time of his death, Article 17(5) of the same law provided that
UAE law shall apply to wills made by aliens disposing of their real property located in the State.
Moreover, Article 1/2 of the UAE Personal Status Law states that “the provisions of the law shall
apply to non-UAE nationals unless the foreigner elects to apply his or her personal status law”.
It could be understood then that when a foreigner dies in the UAE leaving assets in the country,
his or her home country law could be applied based on Article 17/1 and that his or her heirs can
request the court for the application of their own country law as well. However, Article 17/5 puts
a limitation to the freedom of disposition of assets by a foreigner with regard to his or her real
properties located in the country.
Inheritance rules in the UAE always has an element of judicial discretion. Judges are not bound
by precedents or decisions made by other courts and higher courts in a similar case. Judges
make their decisions in accordance with the dictates of their conscience and the principles of
Shariah. There are a number of cases decided by the courts applying Shariah and UAE law to
wills made by foreigners disposing of their assets here. But there are also cases decided by the
courts granting the application of the foreigner’s home country law.
One such case is Cassation Case No. 3/1998. This is a case of a Hindu man who died leaving a
will naming his son as the only heir. Upon his death, the deceased’s mother obtained an order
from the Court of First Instance and later the Court of Appeals for the division of the deceased
assets. The court ordered that one-sixth of the asset will go to the mother, one-eighth to the wife
and the remainder of the asset to the son. The wife of the deceased filed an application to the
High Court to nullify the order of division of the asset and to give the entire estate to the son
who was named as the sole heir in the will in accordance with the law of India.
The court of cassation overruled the orders of the lower courts. It pointed out that the case was
for the enforcement of the will and not for the amendment of division of assets as what the lower
courts propounded. The court clarified that the will should not be affected by the Personal
Status rule that the testator may not pass on property to any of his or her heirs without the
consent of the other heirs. Since the deceased and his family are not UAE nationals and they
are not Muslims, then the law that they have chosen to apply should be applied. While this
decision allowed non-Muslim residents to apply their home country law with regard to their wills,
such laws will not be applied if they offend public policy. In this case, it does not offend public
If courts in many cases applied Sharia law in matters of will of a non-Muslim, non-UAE national
– why still make a will?
Regardless of this fact, it is always advisable to have a will rather than no will at all to document
testator’s intentions. It gives comfort that something has been done to protect one’s family in
case of any eventuality, even though it does not give the guarantee which one expect.
In a judgment rendered by the Court of Cassation in case No. 90/2006, if the heirs was between
non-Muslims regardless of their religion (Christian, Jew or Hindu), deceased law can be applied
in case of death even if the distribution of the deceased law differ from Sharia law. Sharia rules
and principles are not breached as far as none of the parties are UAE national or a foreign
It is important to note here that the judgment contradict the official interpretation of Law No. 28
of 2005 which considered that applying foreign law shall not contradict Sharia principles.
About Author: Mr. Hassan Elhais is one of the renown Family lawyers in Dubai. Advocate
Hassan Elhais has been practicing as a Professional Legal Consultant and property lawyer
since 2005 in Dubai, UAE.