Justice Antonin Scalia—The Wrong Message .pdf
Original filename: Justice Antonin Scalia—The Wrong Message.pdf
This PDF 1.3 document has been generated by Adobe InDesign CC 2015 (Windows) / Adobe PDF Library 15.0, and has been sent on pdf-archive.com on 23/05/2016 at 21:35, from IP address 157.139.x.x.
The current document download page has been viewed 498 times.
File size: 191 KB (2 pages).
Privacy: public file
Download original PDF file
pii: jc- 00141-16 http://dx.doi.org/10.5664/jcsm.5778
E DI TOR IA L S
Justice Antonin Scalia—The Wrong Message
Nancy A. Collop, MD, FAASM
The Emory Clinic Sleep Disorders Center, Atlanta, GA; Editor-In-Chief, Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine
I read with interest the reports that Justice Antonin Scalia was
found dead in bed with his CPAP neither attached to him nor
even plugged in. Many of the news reports noted that: “…the
chance of death from skipping a single day is tiny, and patients
can and do take breaks because they have a cold, forget to take
the machine on a short trip or because the masks are irritating.
Typically the only immediate ill effects are snoring and possibly getting up at night gasping.” 1 But oh how I wished the message was different! Given Justice Scalia’s reported comorbid
illnesses and his probable severe sleep apnea (I am guessing
his neck circumference at least 18+ inches), the likelihood that
he died of either a cardiac arrhythmia, massive stroke or pulmonary embolism is quite high. We will never know if he wore
his CPAP that night, would he be alive today, however it is
likely that if he had been using his CPAP that night, assuming
the final event was a cardiovascular event, there would have
been a reduced likelihood of a mortal event.
Reportedly, Justice Scalia’s death certificate listed the cause
of death as “myocardial infarction” although the county judge
who completed the death certificate noted that he “died of
natural causes.” No autopsy was performed and the death certificate was not released to the public (in Texas that takes 25
years). Rear Admiral Brian Monahan, Scalia’s physician, did
state in a letter that he suffered from “sleep apnea, degenerative joint disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and
high blood pressure.” What we don’t know if any of these disorders were listed on his death certificate—but it is important
that sleep disorders do start getting listed on death certificates.
Having a sleep disorder listed is extremely valuable as these
contain important data used by policy makers to prioritize
public health agendas and funding health care and research2;
it would also raise the level of consciousness about the seriousness of these disorders.
Sleep disorders in general and sleep apnea in particular are
challenging disorders to manage as often the patient has little
awareness of the problem. The patient will come to medical attention via their bedpartner or because of a comorbid condition
that puts them at high risk of having OSA (e.g. resistant hypertension or stroke). We, as sleep specialists, labor to convince
the patient that the disorder is serious and that the treatment
is necessary. I usually show the patient the sleep study results
and go over it in some detail, pointing out the dips in oxygen levels, the length of apneic and hypopneic events and the
sleep disruption accompanying the sleep disordered breathing
events. I try to link the symptoms they have to the sleep study
results: “it is like someone shaking you awake every minute,
all night long.” I wonder, did Justice Scalia’s doctor do this?
Did he appreciate how important it was to use his CPAP? He
had it with him so he knew it was needed; he just did not wear
it. Interestingly, he was also sleeping on three pillows—adding
further evidence to potential breathing difficulties at night. As
noted, Justice Scalia had COPD, diabetes, coronary artery disease, high blood pressure and abused tobacco—all conditions
that confer risk for significant hypoxemia and increase risk for
a cardiac arrhythmia.
We don’t want to use scare tactics to convince our patients
to use their CPAP nightly. But for patients with cardiovascular risk factors like Justice Scalia, missing their CPAP for
one night could set them up for increased risk of sudden death
and stroke; perhaps even taking it off early may increase the
risk since REM sleep is often later in the night and the most
vulnerable stage of sleep for OSA patients. It has been shown
that OSA patients are more likely to die of sudden death between the hours of 12 midnight and 6 AM,3 and the more
severe their hypoxemia, the higher their risk.4 Additionally
patients who suffer a “wakeup stroke” are more likely to have
OSA.5 And sleep apnea patients are also thought to be of increased risk for a pulmonary embolism.6 Any of these catastrophic events could have happened to Justice Scalia and all
have a potential relationship to his diagnosis of obstructive
When a patient asks me “is it okay to miss using my CPAP?”
my response is to reiterate that whenever they don’t use their
CPAP, they go back to having sleep apnea—perhaps not as bad
as when they were first diagnosed, but with a cumulative effect
of worsening each night without it.7 And if they have all the
risk factors that Justice Scalia had—missing one night may be
deadly. There is much we don’t know about Justice Scalia’s
death however a better message surrounding his lack of CPAP
use that night should have been about the importance of obstructive sleep apnea as a comorbid condition—not downplaying the unknown risk of not using CPAP for one night.
C I TAT I O N
Collop NA. Justice Antonin Scalia—the wrong message.
J Clin Sleep Med 2016;12(5):639–640.
Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, Vol. 12, No. 5, 2016
NA Collop. Editorial
6. Peng YH, Liao WC, Chung WS, et al. Association between obstructive sleep
apnea and deep vein thrombosis/pulmonary embolism: a population-based
retrospective cohort study. Thromb Res 2014;134:340–5.
7. Kohler M, Stoewhas A, Ayers L, et al. Effects of Continuous Positive Airway
Pressure Therapy Withdrawal in Patients with Obstructive Sleep Apnea. Am J
Respir Crit Care Med 2011;184:1192–9.
R E FE R E N CES
1. Cha AE. Did sleep apnea contribute to Justice Scalia’s death? His unplugged
breathing machine raises that question. Accessed 3/10/16. Available from:
2. Nowels D. Completing and Signing the Death Certificate. Am Fam Physician
3. Gami AS, Howard DE, Olson EJ, Somers VK. Day-night pattern of sudden
death in obstructive sleep apnea. N Engl J Med 2005;352:1206–14.
4. Gami AS, Olson EJ, Shen WK, et al. Obstructive sleep apnea and the risk of
sudden cardiac death: a longitudinal study of 10,701 adults. J Am Coll Cardiol
5. Hsieh SW, Lai CL, Liu CK, Hsieh CF, Hsu CY. Obstructive sleep apnea linked
to wake-up strokes. J Neurol 2012;259:1433–9.
Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, Vol. 12, No. 5, 2016
SUBM I SSI O N & CO R R ESPO NDENCE I NFO R M ATI O N
Submitted for publication March, 2016
Accepted for publication March, 2016
Address correspondence to: Nancy A. Collop, MD, FAASM, The Emory Clinic Sleep
Disorders Center, Wesley Woods Health Center, 1841 Clifton Road NE, 5th Floor,
Atlanta, GA 30329; Tel: (404) 728-6925; Fax: (404) 712-8145; Email Address nancy.