PDF ArchiveHistorical archive . public document
2015 . June . 30

petition docs

petition_docs.pdf

PDF 1.3 31 pages 1.14 MB Filed 30/06/2015
Download this PDF
petition_docs.pdf
Web reader . 5 pages of 31
Page 1 of 31, petition docs
1 / 5
Advertisement

File preview

DKT. NO. RETURN DATE: JULY 28, 2015 COMMISSIONER, STATE OF CONNECTICUT DEPARTMENT OF EMERGENCY SERVICES AND PUBLIC PROTECTION and STATE OF CONNECTICUT DEPARTMENT OF EMERGENCY SERVICES AND PUBLIC PROTECTION Plaintiffs, SUPERIOR COURT JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF NEW BRITAIN AT NEW BRITAIN : : : : : JUNE 26,2015 ok fac FREEDOM OF INFORMATION COMMISSION and DAVID ALTIMARI AND THE HARTFORD COURANT Defendants. ts. co m V. : : : : : : : yh o PETITION FOR ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL TO THE SUPERIOR COURT for the Judicial District of New Britain at New Britain, sa nd on June 26, 2015, comes the Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency w. Services and Public Protection and State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and ww Public Protection appealing from a final decision of the Freedom of Information Commission (FOIC), dated May 13, 2015 in docket FIC # 2014-372 with a May 15, 2015 Notice of Final Decision, pursuant to Connecticut General Statutes §1 -206(d) and § 4-183 and complains and says that: 1. The plaintiffs are the Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection and the State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection, an agency of the State of Connecticut, with its principal offices located at 1111 Country Club Road, Middletown, CT 06457. 2. The defendant, Freedom of Information Commission, is an agency of the State of Connecticut, with its principal offices located at 18-20 Trinity Street, Hartford, Connecticut 06106, 3. The defendants, David Altimari and the Hartford Courant have a principal place of business at 285 Broad Street, Hartford, Connecticut. 4. On June 11, 2014, the defendants David Altimari and the Hartford Courant filed a ts. co m letter of complaint and appealed to the Freedom of Information Commission (FOIC), alleging that the plaintiffs, Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and fac Public Protection and State of Connecticut Department of Emergency Services and Public ok Protection had violated the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), Conn. Gen. Stat. §§1-200, et. yh o seq., by denying his requests for copies of property seized pursuant to a search warrant in 5. sa nd connection with the Sandy Hook Elementary School shootings. Evidence logs and descriptions of the items seized were included in the report that ww w. was publicly released and are accessible online on the plaintiffs' website. 6. Defendants' request, however, sought copies of the seized property. 7. On January 6, 2015, the matter was heard as a contested case before FOIC Hearing Officer, Attorney Kathleen Ross. 8. At the January 6, 2015 hearing, the plaintiffs moved to bifurcate the hearing to first determine whether the items of private property seized pursuant to search warrants were "public records" under FOIA and to defer consideration of whether any exemptions applied to the property. 2 9. The hearing officer subsequently denied the motion to bifurcate and a second hearing was held on February 19, 2015. 10. The Public Records Administrator for the Connecticut State Library, who is responsible for the design and implementation of a public records management program for state agencies, offered uncontroverted testimony that seized property is not included in the public record retention schedule because an item of seized property is not a "public record". Rather, it ts. co m is purely private property subject to the control and return to its owner by order of the Superior Court. The Chief States Attorney and state police witnesses offered uncontroverted fac 11. ok testimony that property seized pursuant to a warrant is subject to the control of the Superior yh o Court and return by order of the Superior Court under Conn.Gen.Stat. 54-36a et.seq. and 54-33a 12. sa nd et.seq.. It is uncontroverted that seized property is bagged and sealed if possible and ww w. stored in evidence rooms. Access to seized property is limited in order to maintain the chain of custody of the seized property and to ensure the integrity of the property. 13. In this regard, seized documents are no different than other items of seized property, e.g. money, articles of clothing, cell phones, and any other piece of property that is not a document. 14. The Chief States Attorney offered uncontroverted testimony that a finding that evidence seized pursuant to a search warrant is a public record would undermine the functioning of his office and raise serious chain of custody concerns for criminal prosecutions and related civil litigation. In addition, such a finding would potentially undermine the integrity of seized 3 property for return to its owner. Finally, the precedent of such a finding could violate the privacy of crime victims. 14. On April 21, 2015, the Hearing Officer issued a Report of Hearing Officer making proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law. A copy of the Report of Hearing Officer is attached as Exhibit A. 15. On May 13, 2015, the parties were heard before the full FOI Commission at a 16. ts. co m hearing to consider the Report of Hearing Officer. The full Commission adopted the Report of the Hearing Officer and the Notice of fac Final Decision was issued on May 15, 2015. A copy of the Final Decision is attached hereto as The FOIC ordered that copies of the seized property be provided to the yh o 17. ok Exhibit B. sa nd defendants. The plaintiffs have exhausted all available administrative remedies. 19. The plaintiffs are aggrieved by said final decision in that substantial rights of the ww w. 18. plaintiffs have been prejudiced by the Freedom of Information Commission. 20. The Final Decision is erroneous in one or more of the following ways: a. it failed to bifurcate the adjudication of the defendants' complaint to determine in the first instance whether the requested items were "public records"; b. it required plaintiffs to disturb the chain of custody and integrity of the seized property in order assert specific exemptions prior to a finding that the requested items were in fact "public records"; 4 c. it erroneously concluded that the requested items of seized personal property were public records within the meaning of Connecticut General Statutes §§ 1-200(5) and 1-210(a); d. it failed to conclude that seized property is under the control of the judicial branch and thus is not a public record. Clerk of Superior Court v. Freedom of Information Com'n, 278 Conn. 28, 37 (2006); Conn.Gen.Stat54-36a et.seq. . e. it erroneously concluded that property seized for limited purposes under the ts. co m Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution is a public record and must be released without notice to its owner. ok conclusions of law, decision and order are: fac 21. The defendant Freedom of Information Commission's administrative findings of fact, yh o a. in violation of constitutional or statutory provisions; sa nd b. in excess of the statutory authority of the agency; c. made upon unlawful procedure; ww w. d. affected by other error of law; e. clearly erroneous in view of the reliable, probative, and substantial evidence on the whole record; or f. arbitrary or capricious or characterized by abuse of discretion or clearly unwarranted exercise of discretion. 5 WHEREFORE, the plaintiffs respectfully request the Court to reverse the decision of the defendant Freedom of Information Commission remand the matter for further appropriate proceedings consistent with the Court's decision, and/or to grant such other relief as may be deemed appropriate. yh o ok fac ts. co m PLAINTIFF Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection and State of Connecticut Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection sa nd GEORGE JEPSEN ATTORNEY GENERAL w. BY: ww Steven M. Barry Assistant Attgtfney General 110 Sherman Street Hartford, CT 06105 Tel: (860) 808-5450 Fax:(860) 808-5591 Juris No. 433779 steven.barry@ct.gov 6 ts. co m fac ok yh o sa nd w. ww EXHIBIT A i;a Since 1975 * 1 V>n. v It's Your Right to Know 'V'Tv FREEDOM OF INFORMATION f»|p> CcmnecticHl Freedom pf Information Commission • 18-20 Trinity Street, Suite 300 • Hartford, CT 06106 Toil free (Cf only): (866)374-3617 Tel: (860)566-5682 Fax: (860)366-6474 • www.5iaic.ci.iis/fni/ • tmaii: foi@po.staie.ct.us Dave Altimari and the Hartford Courant, Complainants) against Notice of Meeting Docket #FIC 2014-372 Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection; and State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection, Respondent(s) April 21, 2015 ts. co m Transmittal of Proposed Final Decision ' ww w. sa nd yh o ok fac In accordance with Section 4-179 of the Connecticut Genera! Statutes, the Freedom of Information Commission hereby transmits to you the proposed finding and decision prepared by the hearing officer in the above-captioned matter. This will notify you that the Commission wilJ consider this matter for disposition at its meeting which will be held in the Freedom of Information Commission Hearing Room, 18-20 Trinity Street, 1st floor, Hartford, Connecticut, at 2 p.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2015. At that time and place you will be allowed to offer oral argument concerning this proposed finding and order. Oral argument shall be limited to ten (10) minutes. For good cause shown, however, the Commission may increase the period of time for argument. A request for additional time must be made in writing and should be filed with the Commission ON OR BEFORE May 1, 2015. Such request MUST BE (1) copied to all parties, or if the parties are represented, to such representatives, and (2) include a notation Indicating such notice to all parties or their representatives. Although a brief or memorandum of law is not required, if you decide to submit such a document, an original and fourteen (14) copies must be filed ON OR BEFORE May 1, 2015. PLEASE NOTE: Any correspondence, brief or memorandum directed to the Commissioners by any party or representative of any party MUST BE (1) copied to all parties, or if the parties are represented, to such representatives, (2) include a notation indicating such notice to all parties or their representatives and (3) be limited to argument. NO NEW EVIDENCE MAY BE SUBMITTED. If you have already filed a brief or memorandum with the hearing officer and wish to have that document distributed to each member of the Commission, it is requested that fifteen f15) copies be filed ON OR BEFORE May 1, 2015, and that notice be given to all parties or if the parties are represented, to their representatives, that such previously filed document is being submitted to the Commissioners for review. By Order of the Freedom of InformatfoWCemmissio^ t nHr/' JT - ) V I J. JTl. -rf W, Paradis Acting Clerk of the Commission Notice to: William Fish, Esq. Steven M. Barry, Esq. and Lynn D. Wittenbrink, Esq. 2015-04-21/FIC# 2014-372/Trans/wrbp/KKR/fTAH An Affirmative Action/Equal Opportunity Employer FREEDOM OF INFORMATION COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CONNECTICUT Report of Hearing Officer In the Matter of a Complaint by Dave Altimari and the Hartford Courant, Complainants Docket #FIC 2014-372 against fac ts. c om Commissioner, State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection; and State of Connecticut, Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection, April 21, 2015 ok Respondents sa nd yh o The above-captioned matter was heard as a contested case on January 6,2015 and February 19,2015, at which times the complainants and the respondents appeared, stipulated to certain facts and presented testimony, exhibits and argument on the complaint. w. After consideration of the entire record, the following facts are found and conclusions of law are reached: ww 1. The respondents are public agencies within the meaning of §1-200(1), G.S. 2. It is found that, by letter dated January 24, 2014, the complainants requested from the respondents, copies of certain documents referenced in the state police1 report pertaining to the December 14, 2012 shootings at Sandy Hook Elementary School ("SHES").2 Such documents shall be referred to herein as "the requested documents." 'The State Police is a division within the respondent Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection. 2Some of the specific items requested include "a spiral bound book written by the shooter entitled 'The Big Book of Granny';" "class photo of the Class of2002-2003 at SHES;" "a yellow folder containing hand drawn comic- style pictures and stories about Pokeraon-type characters;" "packet containing educational information from SHES for the shooter, including report cards and IEPs;" "list of problems and requests from the shooter to Nancy;" "'Lovebound'" - screenplay or script describing a relationship between a 10 year old boy and a 20 year old man;" and "spreadsheet ranking mass murders by name, number killed, number injured, types of weapons used, and disposition." j 1 ! ! j | j

Download petition docs

petition_docs.pdf . PDF . 1.14 MB . 31 pages

Download PDF

File information

File name
petition_docs.pdf
Size
1.14 MB
Pages
31 pages
PDF version
1.3
Produced with
ABBYY FineReader Engine 10 / PlotSoft PDFill 10.0
Filed on
30/06/2015
Page views
1 173
Document ID
petition-docs
MD5
eeae55f85689a970410ced39a88496b5
SHA-512
5429e9b6a30d8179e896911626e224edb12ec42b9521f45f9d9271cf2dfc8b74369198c5a06bc6b139a1367f59ad0e523fea0f73262d065b08b9f45509014e5a

Share this document

This address never changes. It is the one to keep, to send, or to cite.

Shorter, for a text message or a post with a character limit.

To link to this document from a website or a blog.